Peer Reviews

How to peer review content on ResearchHub

Any type of post on ResearchHub is eligible to be peer reviewed on ResearchHub. To do so, navigate to the Reviews tab on the paper menu.

In the Reviews tab, you’ll be prompted to evaluate various aspects of the paper's quality and provide a numerical score as part of your review.

• Overall - please share your overall impressions of the paper.

• Introduction: Does the introduction clearly articulate the research question and provide adequate context? Is the study's significance within the field convincingly established?

• Methods: Does the study design test the authors' hypothesis? Are the methods described in enough detail for independent replication?

• Results: Were the study's finding analyzed and interpreted reasonably? Is the resulting data open and auditable?

• Discussion: Do the results support the authors' conclusions? Are there any alternative interpretations of the study's findings that the authors should have considered?